2 hours ago
2
Amid the carnage of Australia’s musical theatre industry, producers, venue owners, and audiences alike are asking a simple question: “Where is the next Hamilton?”
With its groundbreaking hip-hop score, Lin-Manuel Miranda’s blockbuster reimagined a dry chapter of American history into a contemporary spectacle, kick-starting a global resurgence. Today, however, the local stage is looking starkly quiet.
The sudden, bruising cancellation of Waitress’s Sydney run — following hard on the heels of Beetlejuice’s national tour folding early in Brisbane — coming on top of Aida pulling out of the Adelaide Festival and the decision earlier this year not to proceed with the planned tour of Back to the Future – has left cavernous gaps in schedules nationwide, leaving major Australian cities without anchor shows.
Signs of distress are everywhere. Theatres sit dark; Anastasia tightened its run before school holidays; The Lion King is performing without a full orchestra despite accepting tourism subsidies; and multiple productions have rushed into deep discounting. For producers, breaking even on cheaper seats is preferable to wearing a loss.
Melbourne too, as an anchor to the east coast market, has had its particular struggles with the closure of the State Theatre for renovations, contributing to the squeeze on venues and challenges co-ordinating seasons between Melbourne, Sydney, Brisbane and Adelaide.
“What was once a high-risk business is now a very high-risk business,” Michael Cassel, commercial producer of Hamilton and MJ the Musical, told a recent arts tax summit. The numbers, he noted, simply don’t add up in 2026.
Changing behaviours and soaring costs
It was less than three years ago that all of Sydney’s main stage theatres were fully booked, playing to some 40,000 people a weekend. Post-COVID, the art form hit a high tide of popularity underpinned by pent-up demand and a younger generation introduced to theatre on social media. Harry Potter and the Cursed Child was just wrapping up its run as the longest-running play in Australian history, after opening in February 2019 at a bespoke Princess Theatre in Melbourne.
But audience behaviour has shifted in ways that upset the traditional economic model. John Frost, producer of Waitress, blames a flagging economy, rising interest rates, an on-again, off again war in Iran, and negative budget sentiment for the car crash in consumer confidence.
Theatre-goers have gone from booking months in advance to buying tickets the week of the show. The resulting volatility and loss of advanced sales place immense financial strain on producers. Reactive discounting has also conditioned shrewd, penny-pinching audiences to delay purchases; loyal devotees complain they frequently pay premium prices only to sit next to patrons who secured tickets for less than the cost of their Uber ride home.
The hard truth is that Australia is a small and geographically scattered market trying to play by big-market rules. Replica productions – where an overseas show is copied down to the exact lighting and staging cues – are increasingly complex and costly to mount. Local producers take on the massive overheads of Broadway or the West End, but must achieve a return without the millions of international tourists who bankroll those shows abroad.
Suzanne Jones of the Jones Theatrical Group, which currently has The Book of Morman, Pretty Woman: The Musical, and Mrs Doubtfire – The Musical in market, said the expense of producing world-class live entertainment was increasing at an unsustainable rate.
According to the Michael Cassel Group (MCG), it costs between $10 million and $15 million to replicate a current hit Broadway show in Australia typically capitalised on Broadway between $20 and $30 million – a figure encompassing everything from auditions to costumes. Touring that production between cities adds a further $1.5 million per move. Given these transfer costs, MCG opted not to tour Hamilton to Adelaide and Perth.
Broadway is also struggling
Even Broadway is hurting. According to The New York Times, none of the 18 commercial musicals that opened last season have made a profit yet. Of 46 recent new musicals, which cost a combined $800 million to bring to the stage, only three are in the green.
The common thread between shows still pulling audiences – the likes of Hamilton, The Lion King, and Les Miserables – is their familiarity and undeniable, broad appeal. Each offers a universal story of ambition or familial love anchored by deeply resonant characters. Hamilton went one better, cutting across cultural and creative demographics to introduce entirely new audiences to the art form.
MJ the Musical seems to be an anomaly to the east coast cancellations, doing good business in Perth and playing to sold-out houses in Brisbane as audiences lean into the familiar music back catalogue.
It is a prime example of the “jukebox musical” which stitches existing pop catalogues into often paper-thin linear narratives. While they benefit from a familiar score and a loyal fan base, the artistic quality of such shows can be variable.
“When shows of inconsistent quality sell at the same premium price as blockbusters, it undermines the market,” says one industry insider. “Audiences can smell cynical programming from a mile away. When ticket buyers are treated like data points on a balance sheet rather than patrons of the arts, the bond of trust snaps.”
UK theatre owner and producer Howard Panter acknowledges discounting erodes perceived value. “People still go in this country to see Taylor Swift or Harry Styles,” said Panter, who leads Trafalgar Entertainment, the second-largest operator of UK regional theatres. “I know that’s music, but what seems to be working are shows that audiences know, and quality.”
London’s West End sits in a far healthier position than Broadway. The Olivier-awarded Paddington the Musical is the hot ticket, carrying the promise of cross-generational appeal when it arrives in Australia late 2027 or 2028. It’s a show that is untested outside England, but can one bear in a duffel coat save an entire ecosystem?
Changes to the UK’s tax relief scheme introduced in 2021 and made permanent in April 2025 have been credited with the West End’s resilience and lobby group Live Performance Australia (LPA) wants the same incentives to support commercial and not-for-profit organisations as either a tax deduction, or rebate.
A 2026 survey of UK claimants found the rebate had attracted wider audiences and supported additional performances, niche productions, covered overhead costs, supported financial stability and increase accessibility of the cultural sector. In some cases, tax relief was used to offset losses to allow tickets to be offered free or at the lowest possible price.
Federal Arts Minister Tony Burke has linked any reforms to a review of the federal national cultural policy now under way, while federal Treasury is understood to be hesitant about extending subsidises to commercial producers.
The message out of Treasury is it doesn’t subsidise sport tickets, and doesn’t want to set the same precedent for theatre. Industry counterclaims that a 40 per cent offset or rebate on pre-production costs would be revenue-positive, and refundable offsets are already provided at the federal and state level for screen and digital games.
LPA’s chief executive, Eric Lassen, said its proposal is a proven model to rebuild confidence. “We’ve seen the evidence from the UK and its transformational impact. It makes sense, it can be readily implemented, and it can deliver real impact,” Lassen said.
In the week that Beetlejuice shut down, an original Australian production of Stella premiered at Monash University. The retelling of the life of Miles Franklin received an outpouring of support on socials from music theatre fans hungry for new vital work. It’s the exact kind of original work Monique diMattina and her fellow creatives say should be supported through the rebate.
“We sold very well despite our debut season being at Monash Clayton – a tricky location to market,” diMattina said. “Nevertheless, our season was only made possible by the financial support of a philanthropic super patron – thrilling for us, but galling for the sector. The support we enjoyed is rare as hens’ teeth.”
Sydney’s Lyric and Capitol theatres will be dark for a combined 30 weeks over the next 10 months, putting casual staff out of work. Yet, Foundation Theatres’ chief executive, Graeme Kearns, maintains that the company’s long-term vision to expand its venues at the Star Casino remains unchanged.
“Current economic conditions will change, and demand for great shows will rebound. We won’t alter the trajectory of our theatre building plans for Sydney,” Kearns said. “After working for more than a decade to get to this point, it would be shortsighted to change track now. Demand will return, and when it does, those venues will be filled with people who love what theatre-makers do.”
Nothing beats a live theatre experience, and Panter and Frost as producers agree there is a case for more theatres, not less, even at this time of closures. “Melbourne’s theatre scene is more vivid than Sydney’s,” said Panter, who is scouting for venues in Australia to tour Trafalgar’s shows. “There’s just more of it, and it goes back to my point, that theatre districts create bigger audiences, and we need more joined-up thinking. The notion of more theatres that run holistically is going to help – you will be able to plan ahead better for more productions and there won’t be gaps [in schedules].”
What lies ahead for the theatre sector?
Looking ahead, Frost is bringing two commercial plays and a musical to Australia next year, as Broadway also pivots to plays. “There are shows having a tough time, and they are the majority, but bookings for My Fair Lady are very solid and building every day,” Frost said. The co-production between Opera Australia and Crossroads Live will head to the Sydney Opera House before opening Melbourne’s revamped Arts Centre in November.
Panter predicts he’s on a winner with Fiddler on the Roof and a brand-new production of Noel Coward’s Private Lives, starring Hugh Bonneville and Lisa McCune, at the Theatre Royal Sydney.
Other award winners like Dear Evan Hansen remain a difficult sell to the mainstream Australian public and increasingly, these titles are being left to subsidised state companies or independent theatre groups.
The shift may point to a more sustainable future of non-replica productions, where the rights to a script and score are secured, but local creatives build the physical staging from scratch, allowing for smarter, lighter, more versatile designs tailored for domestic touring.
The financial bonus for local producers is substantial, as they can bypass certain international royalty structures. However, as Frost cautions, international teams are often reluctant to authorise non-replica versions, and the wait for these rights can take several years, by which time local audience buzz may have completely extinguished.
The industry also thrives on sudden lightning strikes. Lin-Manuel Miranda and Eisa Davis recently announced their highly anticipated new project The Warriors, to open on Broadway next year. Nothing is guaranteed in the historic boom-and-bust cycle of musical theatre, but could this be a title to remind the world of the joys of musical theatre?
Trafalgar is developing an English-language production of Death Note, based on a best-selling anime comic which sold more than 30 million copies in Japan and Korea. A musical thriller set in Tokyo with all Japanese characters is not your usual subject but evidence, says Panter, that nimbleness will pay dividends.
Don’t ever write off musical theatre, cautions Frost: “I’ve been in this business more years than I care to remember, and it’s always had its ups and downs. There is always a show that comes over the hill – one that no one saw coming – that is capable of turning everything around. It’s just a matter of when.”
Want to read more about arts and theatre?
- A second musical hit closes its doors
- ‘Deeply disappointing’: Music company folds after more than four decades
- ‘Difficult decision’: National tour of Musical axed
- This is the best thing I’ve seen all year
Start the day with a summary of the day’s most important and interesting stories, analysis and insights. Sign up for our Morning Edition newsletter.
